The most important thing first
A scanned signature is only unproblematic in Switzerland where neither the law nor the contract requires a form. As soon as written form is required, the scan is not enough, and even as evidence it is weak. For such cases, depending on the situation, an advanced or a qualified electronic signature is needed.
Our experience with the signing platform actaSIGN® shows: the real sticking point is rarely the technology, but the legal form. Many people want to send documents quickly as PDFs, but forget that a scan is legally only an image. That is exactly where disputes later arise.
When is a scanned signature permissible in Switzerland?
For contracts without form requirements, a scanned signature can practically work, because the contract arises from the aligned expressions of will, not from the signature image. This concerns, for example, orders, purchase agreements for movable goods, or ordinary employment contracts. Legally, the scan does not replace the form; it provides at most a weak evidentiary document.
The problem is evidentiary strength: anyone who receives the PDF can insert the same image into another document. If the other party later disputes the signature, the scan cannot securely show who inserted it or whether the document was altered later.
Why does the scan not suffice for written form?
As soon as the law or the contract requires simple written form, the handwritten signature is basically required. Electronically equated only the qualified electronic signature with a qualified timestamp. A mechanically reproduced signature does not suffice, except in legally prescribed special cases, which are not the norm for contracts.
Typical pitfalls are a non-compete clause in an employment contract, the assignment of a claim, or a contractually agreed written form for changes. If the correct form is missing there, the agreement is invalid. If you rely only on the scan, you may save minutes now but risk the validity of the document later.
article_text
Which signature fits instead of a scanned signature?
| Situation | Scanned signature | FES | QES |
|---|---|---|---|
| Form-free contract, low risk | valid, weak evidence | valid, good evidence | valid |
| Form-free contract, dispute potential | evidence risk | valid | valid |
| Legally required written form, e.g., non-compete | invalid | invalid | valid |
| Contractually agreed written form | invalid | only if not otherwise agreed | valid |
| Notarization, will | invalid | invalid | invalid |
For form-free documents with dispute potential, an advanced electronic signature is often the pragmatic choice. It is clearly linked to the signing person and makes subsequent changes detectable. Where written form applies, there is no way around the QES.
With actaSIGN® both levels can be combined in one process. External parties confirm the FES via SMS code, the QES is performed via the Mobile ID App. This speeds up companies' signing and approval processes and reduces paper usage.
Frequently asked questions
Is a scanned signature in an email attachment always invalid?
What is the difference between a scan, FES and QES?
What happens if a contract is signed without sufficient form?
Can I use actaSIGN® to sign only a part digitally?
If you are unsure about a scanned signature, it is worthwhile to first look at the form requirement, not the signature image. For form-free cases a scan can suffice; for written form, the right electronic or handwritten signature is required. A clean solution like actaSIGN® helps here by combining legal certainty with digital processes.
Unterschriftsprozesse digital und rechtssicher klären
axelity ag, Sargans
